Men’s True Penny: Made to Order

Rated 3.8 out of 5
Based on 28 reviews
$300.00 USD
Return Policy

Custom (Made To Order) products are personalized based on your design choices and, therefore, not returnable for refund or exchange (unless there is a defect in material or craftsmanship of the product). We want you to love your new custom footwear purchase as much as we enjoy handcrafting them for you so if you are not 100% satisfied with your custom order, we will quickly address your concern. Please contact service@quoddy.com or call (207) 853-2488 to discuss how we can help correct any issues. Most of the time issues are with fit and many of those be resolved and we will gladly work to adjust the fit for you: Of course, it’s best to minimize any fit issues ahead of your purchase so click on this link to see our fit guide or feel free to call customer service for direction ahead of time and we will help walk you through the process. For more information on our return policy, please visit this link.

average rating 3.8 out of 5
Based on 28 reviews
  • 5 Stars
    14 Reviews
  • 4 Stars
    4 Reviews
  • 3 Stars
    4 Reviews
  • 2 Stars
    2 Reviews
  • 1 Star
    4 Reviews
64% of reviewers would recommend this product to a friend
28 Reviews
Reviewed by Justin, from United States
I recommend this product
Rated 5 out of 5
Review posted

Great Fit and Finish

These are my third pair of Quoddy shoes (canoe shoe, Penny Driver) and like the other two pairs I am very satisfied. The Cavalier Whiskey color is very striking and rich in color and should patina nicely. These fit like gloves right out of the box and I'm hoping will continue to fit great after whatever break-in they go though. The lining is a nice added touch and helps give it a little more structure without cramping my foot. Sipped sole is a nice added touch. I sized down a full size to an 11 from 12 in the other two pairs of shoes I have from Quoddy as they seem to run large after broken in and so far, so good.

Loading...
Was this helpful?
Reviewed by Brian D., from United States
Verified Buyer
I don't recommend this product
Rated 1 out of 5
Review posted

Heal grip loose

Disappointed with shoes. The sole grip on both heals falling apart. Will look for different brand.

Loading...
Was this helpful?
Reviewed by Nathan C., from United States
Verified Buyer
I recommend this product
Rated 5 out of 5
Review posted

outstanding penny loafers

beautiful, low profile penny loafer. The full moccasin construction is really evident with these. I followed the sizing advice and went down a half size from my normal Quoddy size that I have used on bluchers and the Telos chukka. At a half size down from these, the penny loafers were very snug on the first wear. They have a pretty narrow toe. If you have a wide foot I would be skeptical that you would be able to go a half size down, but for me it worked. By the third wear, the loafers stretched enough to conform to my foot but with no slip in the heel while wearing thin socks. That was what I was going for, so the sizing advice worked great for me. The sipped sole really increases the flexibility of these and increases the feeling that you are wearing moccasins. These hit all the marks for me for style, sizing, comfort and craftsmanship-- great job, Quoddy!

Loading...
Was this helpful?
Reviewed by Michael K., from United States
Verified Buyer
I recommend this product
Rated 5 out of 5
Review posted

Excellent service and excellent shoes.

Elizabeth provided awesome service, including the reordering process to go up 1/2 size. I wear a 12D and sizing down 1/2 size, as recommended by the website, was uncomfortably snug. The final loafers look and fit great. Well made. Excellent service. Quality USA made product. Great company to support!

Loading...
Was this helpful?
Reviewed by Philip B., from United States
Verified Buyer
Rated 3 out of 5
Review posted

tight

1. very long period from order to delivery

2. love pennys but too tight, returning for expantion

3. color seems dull

Loading...
Was this helpful?
Subscribe To

Quoddy News

×